Sunday, February 17, 2008

Occasional Reviews: The Comics Journal #288

I used to read The Comics Journal when I was 13 years old. I'm not sure if I was supposed to do that. I don't even remember how I got my hands on a copy. Don't tell anyone.

By the time I was 16, I learned that a comic book's real worth was its investment value, and that The Comics Journal was stupid because it didn't have enough Marvel & DC. This opinion waned a bit when I was in college, as the articles in said publication fulfilled my required academic reading for my self-made pop-culture interdisciplinary concentration (read: studies that enriched my life but would never get me a six-figure income, and barely a five-figure income).

When I started working for the comic book industry, I regained the opinion that The Comics Journal was stupid because it didn't have enough Marvel & DC, and too many foreign people to boot. At that time, we were all metaphorically trying to get into Wizard's pants, anyway.

The boom in comic blogging brought the idea of comics journalism/studies back in my mind. And while there was a number of really great blogs analyzing comics, I did miss the feel of an actual document in my hands filled with vetted articles of academic import. Of course, the argument can be made that the print magazine is a dinosaur and that Fantagraphics Press would be better off putting the whole Comics Journal shebang online. But, if we buy that argument then I think the fate of the actual comics themselves are fast behind on the queue.

I don't drop $11.95 on a magazine lightly. But, when I saw that The Comics Journal was in a brand new format as of issue #288 -- and offered a collection of full-color Miss Fury strips to boot -- I decided to give it a shot.

It's a strikingly handsome volume -- its smaller, chunkier feel and arty cover design removing it somewhat from periodical-land, and something more along the lines of Fantagraphic Press's non-journalistic offerings. I think this is a smart move on their part. If the print magazine industry is waning, I think the key would be to make your magazine more like a book, or a hybrid of articles and original/reprint content.

The issue boasts, among other things:
* A list of their top picks for 2007. (happy/surprised to see World War Hulk on the list)
* The aforementioned Miss Fury reprints, with an introduction by Trina Robbins
* An essay on Stan Lee
* A feature on Fletcher Hanks's Stardust
* An interview with Exit Wounds' Rutu Modan
Plus a lot more.

While there are some areas in which the Web trumps print -- for instance, the news reports section in the print TCJ gets scooped by their own Journalista every weekday -- the book/magazine format is still ideal for consuming longer-form pieces.

If The Comics Journal sticks with the new design/format (and perhaps continues the reprints), I'll stick with it.

PS: Don't pull the sticker off the cover. Just leave it alone.


  1. thrice-damned stickers!

  2. I never had a speculator/investor phase (sorry to admit I'd probably say that in a snotty tone of voice in a real conversation), but I did sometimes get a little tired of their willful ignore-the-big-two act. Still, I was a loyal Journal reader for years, and would even keep picking it up when I was'nt picking up comics at all.
    For the past few years, though, I tell people that I'll start buying it regularly again if I read the lottery.

  3. I dropped TCJ because it was starting to read like what would happen if George Will and the guy who wrote the license agreement/terms of service for Microsoft Windows decided to team up and do a comix magazine. You could count on a minimum of seven paragraphs before the writer started mentioning the actual subject at hand; if the writer used the words "zeitgeist" and "gestalt" in the opening sentence, you had to chug a beer.

    But it often had interviews and features that were worth the cost of the whole magazine. I'll be looking forward to the relaunched edition.

  4. Hey, thanks for the writeup... we're aware of the sticker problem, by the way, and the sticker on the next issue will be less sticky.