Pages

Showing posts with label Legion Of The Superheroes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Legion Of The Superheroes. Show all posts

Thursday, October 30, 2008

Jim Shooter's Legion Blues


You can always count on Jim Shooter to provide a frank -- if unflinching -- perspective on things. His interview with CBR regarding his departure(s) from Legion Of The Superheroes -- and the current title's demise -- is no exception.

In the interview, Shooter goes over what he felt was his own failures on the series -- as well as expressing the opinion that he was treated to an extent unfairly by DC. In fact, he goes so far as to allege that the real reason Legion is being cancelled at #50 is to get rid of him:

"Sales of ‘The Legion of Super-Heroes’ aren’t great, but they’re a lot better than those of some of the titles they’re keeping. I think canceling the book is a graceful way of getting rid of me. I complain too much and too loudly.

I'm torn on this issue, as I do have a great amount of respect for Legion editor Mike Marts. I worked with him at Acclaim Comics, and he is a class act all the way.

On the other hand, I think Shooter is an elder statesman of comics, and especially of Legion of the Superheroes. He originally wrote the title, I believe, while still a teenager. I know he has a reputation of being persnickety, outspoken, and uncompromising, but I still think he is a dedicated and talented writer.

Further, in a world full of spin and passing the buck, Shooter in that interview reserved the biggest criticism for himself:


"But let’s focus on the real culprit – me. I guess what it really all comes down to is that my work wasn’t good enough to overcome all the small problems further down the line. If you’re out at first base, it doesn’t matter if you slide in at second."

I said this once about John Byrne, and I'll say it now about Jim Shooter -- like him or hate him, he's one of those people who had an enormous impact on this industry, and will always be remembered as one of the key figures in comic book history. I'm sad to see him leave the title he was so much a part of on such a bitter note.

That said, if I had to guess, I would think that Geoff Johns' own plans for Legion probably played a part in both the problems with the book and its subsequent cancellation. Perhaps at some point DC decided that they really wanted to go with Johns' plans for the book more, and so in the battle for competing visions for the future of the title, Shooter lost.

This not to suggest that Johns in any way specifically was looking to jettison Shooter's Legion. This the way things fall sometimes. That said, it would have been far better to let Shooter's story be told first, give him some room, and wait before launching a new direction on the book.

I wish Shooter's return on Legion didn't have to end so abruptly.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Rumor Of The Week

From LITG:

"I understand that Marvel have been playing wargames on how to persuade Geoff Johns to jump ship at the end of his contract (over a year away) and what to do with him when they get him, so expect to see DC Comics fight back pre-emptively…"


dude.

Geoff Johns at Marvel?

Could that happen?

What would he work on?

I said it before -- I think Johns is the foundation of the DCU.

So if -- theoretically -- he was to go to Marvel, would he be engaged in similar "world-building?"

As always, this is just speculation.

Also, according to the same column, Shooter is back on "Legion."

And Nova isn't canceled, which makes the BF happy. :-)


Sunday, January 06, 2008

Occasional Reviews: Legion, Incredible Herc, and Dorian Gray


Legion of the Superheroes #37
Writer: Jim Shooter

Artists: Francis Manapul & Livesay

Publisher: DC Comics

Seeing Jim Shooter back on Legion of the Superheroes -- the series he wrote so many moons ago as a teenager -- is sort of like putting on a comfortable old pair of sneakers. You get the impression that he knows these heroes inside-and-out. And when you hear Phantom Girl call a fellow Legionnaire by a personal, dare say obscure, pet name, you wonder if that's how Shooter himself refers to the character.

The layout for this issue is very reminiscent of those he did (or mandated) for early Valiant comics like Harbinger and Magnus Robot Fighter. There are relatively many panels per page; though true to his "classic comics" storytelling philosophy, there's an economy to the process. Every panel means something -- whether it's a beat, a crucial action, or a plot point.

This said, the problem in Legion of the Superheroes #37 for me lies in the art not matching the needs of the storytelling approach. Francis Manapul is a very talented artist -- he has a slick, modern "Wildstorm" type style. But it doesn't quite complement Shooter's writing. The multitude of panels shrinks Manapul's figures (sometimes to outrageously tiny size) and robs them of their detail & impact.

A multitude of panels and dialogue crowds out the art and discourages the reader

Again, this is neither a critique of Shooter or Manapul -- simply an observation. In a scene halfway through the story depicting a brawl, the art works great, because it's mostly action and there are relatively few panels and word balloons. The art has a chance to breathe. But in the issue as a whole, the art is too crammed and it is both distracting & discouraging in terms of my desire to continue reading this series.

I've heard the old chestnut many times -- pair up an older "Classic" writer with a "Hot" young artist to assure sales. (Thank God this was not done with Jim Starlin on Death Of The New Gods.) But a traditional Valiant-style artist (say, David Lapham back in the day), would have served the story so very much better.

An example of the "Shooter" storytelling style from "Harbinger" where the artist makes it work

So my recommendation for Legion would be to either get a new art team or edit Jim Shooter's writing down...and really, it would be far easier to just get a new art team.

Rating: B-
Would I buy again?: Not unless the art situation was addressed.


The Incredible Hulk #112
Writers: Greg Pak & Fred Van Lente
Artists: Khoi Pham & Stephane Peru

Publisher: Marvel Comics


I really thought this book would suck. But surprisingly, it's quite good.

It's just that when I hear things like "they're bringing The Champions back" and "it's Hercules in "Hard Travelin' Heroes," I start to worry.

(Boy Genius) team up to kick "The Incredible Herc" is actually a very well-written and -drawn offbeat spinoff sprouted directly from the pages of World War Hulk. In it, Hercules (Strong Man) and Amadeus Cho (Boy Genius) kick SHIELD's ass (or at least give them a wedgie). Along the way they might each move past their respective godlike abilities and help each other be a little more human.

Absoutely stunning art by Khoi Pham & Stephane Peru

Pak & Van Lente give Hercules a believable "voice" that escapes the trap of "camp" but certainly doesn't take itself too seriously, either. Their Hercules is very much its own unique quanity, neither that of the movies or TV adaptations.

Pham & Peru have beautifully rendered this story, hitting all the requisite beats in terms of emotion and nuance. This level of art is usually reserved for "A List" titles or prestige projects -- not quirky Hulk spinoffs. Enjoy it.

Rating: A
Would I buy again?: Yes


The Picture of Dorian Gray
Writer: Roy Thomas

Artist: Sebastian Fiumara
Publisher: Marvel Comics

The Picture of Dorian Gray is one of the most beautiful comic books on the stands right now. I always find these classic literature adaptations a very mixed bag -- they can be great, or they can be hacked out under the aegis of "well, it's just educational stuff for the kiddies anyhow." I used to co-edit Acclaim's Classic Illustrated series, and while I'm proud of the original adaptations we produced, the recolored reprints were rather dry.


That said, the art and coloring on The Picture of Dorian Gray is absolutely gorgeous. Which, when you're dealing with a story by Oscar Wilde that in some ways is like Victorian slash fan-fiction, only heightens the reading experience. They should release this is a manga edition and call it "Yummy Painting Life."

I'd buy it in hardcover.

Rating: A
Would I buy it again? Yes, though I would rather have it collected in one volume.

Saturday, October 27, 2007

Karate Kid: Laundry Boy To The Legion


Holy crap, I just watched the latest "Legion of the Superheroes" cartoon.

Okay, so in this Legion universe, Karate Kid is Asian. An Asian martial artist. That's clever. If you're going to have an Asian kid in the Legion, he might as well wear a white karate outfit and be into martial arts.

But it gets better. Karate Kid wants to join the Legion. But he has no superpowers. So they take him into the group on a trial basis. He must prove himself to them and, basically, earn his keep.

So what job do the Legion give him?

LAUNDRY BOY!

They give him a cart with wheels and he has to go to every Legion bunk and pick up their laundry. He is also a great housekeeper.

In return, the Legion makes it clear that he has yet to prove himself to them, and is not really as legit member.

Karate Kid doesn't really hang out with the rest of the group, because they really don't accept him. He is paired off with Chameleon Boy -- ostensibly another "minority" member who also is on thin ice with the Legion.

But as Superman keeps reminding them, Karate Kid may not have fancy-schmancy powers like the rest of them...but he has a strong work ethic! Steaming and pressing Element Lad's sheets and polishing the mess hall, Karate Kid is a role model of what you can accomplish "when you don't have a lot but are willing to work hard."

Through it all, in a fake Asian accent, Karate Kid spouts out pseudo-meaningful nuggets of wisdom about "finding your own destiny" and working despite the odds.

This episode was the most mind-bogglingly patronizing thing I've ever seen since viewing the silent movie "Shadows". In that movie, Lon Chaney takes the role of the wise, stomach-churningly humble, hardworking Asian laundryman. The fact that around 80 years have passed since that film & this cartoon but the Asian protagonist has been portrayed so very similar is troubling.

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

The Kids WB Is RIP


Holy Shmokes!

I just read on The Beat that The CW is discontinuing their Kids WB programming.

From the Toon Zone article:

"The CW has announced it will be shutting down the Kids WB! Saturday morning programming block at the end of the current 2007 - 2008 season. Rival 4Kids Entertainment will handle programming and marketing of the block starting with the new season in September 2008. Some current Kids WB programs may continue to air after the changeover, but no decisions have been have yet."

And this from Variety:


"Warner Bros. TV Group prexy Bruce Rosenblum said the company examined the Saturday morning issue "closely with our partners at CBS," and ultimately decided leasing the space to 4Kids made the most business sense. For example, by farming out Saturday morning, the net believes it can focus more ad sales energy toward the online world."

The Variety article goes on to quote Rosenblum as saying that the WB will still produce cartoons for "cable, direct-to-DVD, broadband and wireless."

And all this just when I was really getting into "Legion of the Superheroes in the 31st Century!"

Damnit.


Friday, September 07, 2007

Jim Shooter on "Legion" -- Thoughts


Examining the news that Jim Shooter & Francis Manapul will be the official team on "Legion of the Superheroes" as of issue #37, I really can't see how DC could screw this up. I mean, it really seems like a winner.

Of course, to drag the series down with "Countdown" lore would be a stumbling block. But honestly, given Shooter's temperment as a writer, I find it unlikely he would cotton to being editorially dictated to. So if Shooter is left more or less alone to be "Shootery" it could work.

But also, "Legion" has always been Paul Levitz's pet book, and I can't see him letting it get dragged in the mediocity that has gripped a good portion of the DC Universe line.

On a related subject -- how charmed is "Legion" editor Mike Marts? First he was freed from "Countdown," then he gets the "Batman" books, which currently are the only DC books I read with any real enjoyment. Honestly, this is the best "Batman" has been (I don't include Frank Miller's "All-Star" as a "real" Bat-book) in many many years. Then he gets Shooter/Manapul on "Legion."

I also wonder if Marts ever worked with Shooter at Acclaim/Valiant during that "Unity" event the company was supposed to put out right before it folded, and how the rapport is between the two of them.

And I'm pretty sure not everybody in the DC offices are thrilled regarding Shooter's return. There is a reason it has taken this long to get him back on "Legion."

I remember Shooter visiting the offices about 4 years ago. All I saw was the very top of his head, somewhere very close to the ceiling. He's quite the presence in person.