Pages

Showing posts with label copyright. Show all posts
Showing posts with label copyright. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Shepard Fairey: Plagiarism Or Art?


I would think many artists use photo or other types of reference at some time or another. It's pretty standard.

But what happens when you have a case like Shepard Fairey's Obama poster -- where not only was extensive referencing of an Associated Press photo used, but the poster itself becomes an international phenomenon?

Is it plagiarism or art? Is it fair use? Did Fairey "transform" the image enough to the point where it has become a separate entity? If he makes money off the image, does the original AP photographer deserve a cut, as well?

Here's another example. The following work is from edgy street artist Rupert Endive:

"Super Heavy Sex Machine No. 9/CRAZE" by Rupert Endive, 2003.
Photograph and Sharpie.


Endive's main "hook" is to put graffiti tags and other sorts of defacement on posters, magazine advertisements, and newspaper headlines. When Endive sells his work, does he owe a cut to the original producers of the material he has "defaced"? Or, because he has added his own ideas to the material -- thus rendering them ironic -- has he created a whole new work of art, beholden to nobody?

And what if instead of an edgy street artist, Endive was just some schmuck with a stack of papers looking to make a buck? How much of this is context? Does being a successful and renowned artist make you more likely to get a free pass on this copyright thing?

And look, I have no definitive opinion either way, other than the fact that I am Rupert Endive's exclusive agent and representative. I'm just throwing questions out there.

Monday, December 01, 2008

Was Emily The Strange Ripped Off???



I was pretty shocked to read about a 1978 children's book that features a character very similar in design and attitude to the highly popular "Goth" character Emily The Strange...

Look at the images above and then read this from the You Thought We Wouldn't Notice website, who spotted the uncanny resemblance:

"The top image is a page from Nate the Great Goes Undercover, complete with text. This book was published in 1978. The bottom image is one of the first images of Emily the Strange ever made publicly available–it was sold, WITH THAT TEXT INCLUDED, as a bumper sticker."

What do you think? Unconscious influence? An homage? Total rip-off?

Glad that bitch Emily is getting what's coming to her:

Sunday, November 09, 2008

Turkey: We Want "Batman" Back


As you may or may not be aware, Batman is not only the name of a DC Comics superhero -- it is also the name of a city in Turkey:

Well guess what?

Now the mayor of Batman, Turkey, Hüseyin Kalkan, is planning to sue for royalties owed to the city of Batman by the makers of "Batman." Specifically, he is going to sue "The Dark Knight" director Christopher Nolan. Because as we all know, Hollywood is where all the money is.

According to Kalkan:

“The royalty of the name ‘Batman’ belongs to us … There is only one Batman in the world. The American producers used the name of our city without informing us...”

While this proposed lawsuit sounds a bit extreme, Kalkan brings up an interesting point. Can or can not people use the Batman name for shops and restaurants and products -- as long as they mean Batman, Turkey?

According to the Hurriyet Daily News:

Şafii Dağ, a former Batman resident, currently living in the Germany city of Wesel, is one of those citizens who cannot use Batman as a title for his business, according to the newspaper. “I named my two restaurants Batman. But six months ago, a team of employees from the production company of the movie Batman made me change the title. Telling them that Batman was the name of my hometown did not change anything,” Dağ said.
Paging Jeff Trexler...

Via io9

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Overfill Dumpster Submissions and Nemesis


In his post "Hiring Policies At DC," Ryan @ Comics Fodder brings up ther topic of the submissions process and how fear of lawsuits might have curtailled it in the comic book industry:

"For most of my life, it was believed you sent scripts to some submissions department at DC and Marvel, and somebody might read the script and give some talented, lucky kid a shot. Of course, all of that was managed by technology. You had to: (a) write the story (b) get the story on a type writer (which meant typing, which used to be considered a skill) (c) presumably photocopy the script so you'd have a copy and one for the publisher (d) Place it in the mail (e) Hope for a phone call but expect a rejection letter"

Sometime around 2001/2002, somebody at DC Comics discovered that there were literally piles upon piles of unanswered submissions lying around their offices. Many of the editors simply didn't want to or didn't have the time to answer the submissions, so they were stashed, unopened, under desks, in file cabinets, etc.

When they were finally collected, they filled at least one entire large metal dumpster cart. I think that might have been from just one editor's office alone.

A skilled member of DC's staff was chosen to spearhead the clean-up effort and get those months and possibly years of unopened submissions answered. Me.

The unofficial "rejections editor" was instructed to send out one of several form letters rejecting the submissions. There were no "acceptance" letters, just rejections.

All self-addressed stamped envelopes and unused postage of any kind were to be returned to the sender, as well as any original plots or other writing. Why the return of the original writing? So the submitters couldn't sue DC for any similar characters or plotlines that might have been created.

Apparently, some of the DC higher-ups were absolutely furious that those submissions had piled up like they did. As a direct result of the "great submissions shame," DC officially changed their policy to "no outside submissions." This, given the circumstances, seemed fair.

I once found a submission that Cry For Dawn creator Joseph Michael Linsner sent for a possible Batman/Dawn crossover in the unopened submissions pile. After briefly bringing it to the attention of my boss, I took the pinup print that was sent of Dawn & Batman and hung it up on my office wall. It would have been thrown away with all the others if I didn't.



Mike Park, in the late Seventies, visited DC with art samples, including an original page of comic art featuring a character he created named Nemesis. Nemesis was unique for a superhero in that he did not wear a costume, just civilian clothes with a trademark turtleneck. The art director at the time, Vince Colletta, thought Park's art was too "underground" in style for DC, but thought he had a great concept with Nemesis.

In 1980, a character named Nemesis debuted in The Brave and the Bold. He was unique for a superhero in that he did not wear a costume, just civilian clothes with a trademark turtleneck. There were allegedly other similarities in the B&B story to the comic story Park had shown DC, specifically regarding a helicopter, but I couldn't really comment in that unless I both read the comics in question & looked at the art again.

Anyway, when Nemesis hit the stands in 1980, Park immediately recognized it as his character. But he had never thought of bringing it up to DC. "I was just too small a fish," he explained to me. But he dutifully collected every appearance of Nemesis, and to this day quietly considers it "his" character.

Park is digging the Nemesis sample out of storage so I can have another look at it & scan it & post it.


Was the Nemesis case that of coincidence, or something more? Regardless, instances like these are why comic book companies get so nervous about unsolicited submissions.


Monday, March 31, 2008

Comic Creator Offers Up Work For "Remixing" Under Creative Commons


Hot on the heels of the Siegel Superman ruling and many Internet discussions on copyrights and public domain, comic creator Dan Goldman ("Shooting War") is offering up his online comic "KELLY" for remixing under Creative Commons:

"Applying open-source ideas to comics has always excited me… and my freakadelic “KELLY” has served as my current laboratory for pushing boundaries in all directions, so it felt natural for me to take this step with this particular project."

Under the licensing agreement, anybody can spread or "remix" Kelly -- as long as they credit the original work and don't make money off of it.

I applaud Goldman on his decision. As an artist utilizing mixed-media and "found" art (who likes to incorporate old comics in her work), this issue of "remixing" is one of particular interest to me. I may have to produce some "Kelly" pieces. :-)