His report concerning FCBD at the shops? Most shops set up special areas where customers could pick the comics they wanted and have them bagged by an employee. He said interactivity between the comic shop staff and the patrons was excellent. The amount of comics each person could receive varied from store-to-store. Some stores threw in DC Universe #0 as a free comic. At one major comics shop, Midtown Comics, there was a line around the block. At Jim Hanley's Universe, he noted that there were many children.
Another view on FCBD from artist Steve Ellis can be read here.
I've made an effort to read most of these comics, and my notes for some are included.
Antarctic Press

Neotopia Color Pocket Manga
Notes: We didn't find this one, but it could be that it was overlooked because of the format, or that they ran out.
Ape Entertainment

Cartoonapalooza #1
Notes: All-new short stories featuring a selection of their regular offerings. White Picket Fences & Femme Noir caught my interest.
Arcana Comics

Arcana Presents
Notes: A sampler of Arcana books, including Kade, The Gwai, Burn, and 100 Girls, all far better comics than I expected.
Aspen Comics

Worlds of Aspen
Notes: A sampler of Aspen titles. I think Aspen has officially taken the T & A title from Top Cow. Is the panel from the Executive Assistant Iris preview, where she is naked from behind ready to sexually service her boss, really appropriate in a Free Comic Book Day publication?
Archie Comics
Jughead at The Geppi Entertainment Museum
Notes: I have to admit, this is one of the more ingenious Archie crossovers, with Jughead working at the real-life Baltimore museum. A take-off on the movie "Night At The Museum."
Archie Comics

Sonic The Hedgehog #1 (reprint edition)
Notes: A reprint of the very first Sonic the Hedgehog comic, showcasing the more cartoony style of the series's earlier stories
Bongo Comics
Bongo Comics Free-For-All
Notes: Featuring a hilarious manga version of The Simpsons, which I'm not sure is reprint material or not but is worth hunting down the book just for that. The book is in a smaller, digest-sized format.
Boom Studios

Salem Queen Of Thorns
Notes: A prequel to Salem Queen of Thorns #1, featuring rogue witchhunter Elias Hooke.
Dark Horse

Hellboy: Free Comic Book Day
Notes: An excellent collection of three short stories featuring the work of Mike Mignola, Duncan Fegredo, Guy Davis, Joshua Dysart, and Paul Azaceta
DC Comics

Tiny Titans #1
Notes: A reprint of the first issue of this title, plus a load of Johnny DC ads.
DC Comics
All-Star Superman #1
Notes: The "All-Star" has been dropped from the cover logo. While the first issue of Grant Morrison's Superman is certainly a top-notch issue, I question DC's decision to have it represent the company's mainstream comic offerings for FCBD. What was the purpose in choosing this? To sell the hardcovers? Or to push Grant Morrison as a writer as a whole, to lead people to buy "Final Crisis?" Was there no other current offering from DC that they could have used?
Dabel Brothers Publishing

Del Rey & Dabel Brothers 2008 Preview
Notes: A sampler of Del Rey/Dabel Brothers titles, including Jim Butcher's Dresden Files, Dean Koontz's Frankenstein & George R. R. Martin's Wild Cards. Dresden Files looks sort of cool, Frankenstein looks interesting though the monster looks sort of like a (heavily scarred) pretty emo boy.
Devil's Due Publishing

Drafted: Free Comic Book Day Edition
Notes: This alien-invasion/end-of-the world saga looks pretty interesting.
Drawn & Quarterly

Gekiga!
Notes: Previews of two Japanese works from the 1960s & 70s, Red Colored Elegy by Seiichi Hayashi & Good-Bye by Yoshihiro Tatsumi.
Dynamite Entertainment
Project Superpowers: The Death-Defying Devil
Notes: One short story featuring the Death Defying Devil & Yellow Claw, and the rest is previews & ads.
Eureka Productions

Graphic Classics Special Edition
Notes: A selection of short stories by Edgar Allen Poe, Mary Shelley, and others. Quite good, and a lot of material offered with a card-stock cover.
Fantagraphics Press

Ignatz
Notes: Short selections from their Ignatz line, with an homage to Krazy Kat by Kevin Huizenga on the cover.
Gemstone Publishing

Walt Disney's Gyro Gearloose
Notes: Five stories, including two by Carl Barks. Makes you wish Gemstone put out more of these.
Gemstone Publishing

EC Sampler
Notes: Four complete stories, including the ultra-paranoid KKK-themed "Under Cover." Great stories, but not for children.
IDW Publishing
Transformers Animated
Notes: Apparently film cels from the animated series rearranged into a story.
Impact

Impact University Volume 4
Notes: Previews and selection from their line of how-to line of books on comic art
Maerkle Press

Love and Capes #7
Notes: FCBD version of issue 7.
Marvel Comics

Free Comic Book Day 2008: X-Men
Notes: Original X-Men story featuring Pixie. I think it significant that the original FCBD story Marvel picked starred a teenage female character with pink hair and fairy wings. I think they are trying to reach out to a younger, more gender-balanced crowd through this FCBD book.
Marvel Comics

Free Comic Book Day 2008: Marvel Adventures
Notes: A complete Marvel Adventures tale starring Iron Man, Hulk, and Spider-Man. Good for kids, but doesn't talk down to them.
Oni Press

Maintenance FCBD
Notes: An enjoyable complete story about time travel gone wrong. Good introduction to the series.
Platinum Studios

Hero By Night: FCBD Edition/Gunplay Preview
Notes: Two previews. Hero By Night does a better job setting up the premise for new readers than Gunplay.
Radical Comics

Imaginary: May 2008
Notes: Previews of Radical's titles, including Hercules, Caliber, and more. Their offerings are very elaborately painted.
Red 5 Comics

Atomic Robo/Neozoic
Notes: My first exposure to Atomic Robo, and very well-done.
Renaissance Press

Amelia Rules! Comics & Stories
Notes: This title, along with Top Shelf's Owly, have cemented themselves as staples of modern comics for kids. Uses a more inexpensive, newsprinty paper stock that I think works fine for kids books.
Rude Dude Productions

The Moth Special Edition 2008
Notes: A Moth story plus sketches & other supplemental material.
Sky Dog Press

Kids Love Comics! Comic Book Diner Special Edition
Notes: A selection of kid comics including Amelia Rules, Buzzboy, Patrick The Wolfboy, and more. Includes a kids comics reading list.
Starbridge Media Group

Nascar Heroes
Notes: Huh. Well I'll be damned, I didn't even know they were licensing this out to comics. Pretty much what you'd expect. I love how the guy on the cover is in that classic Speed Racer pose.
Top Cow Productions
Broken Trinity Prelude
Notes: Is it just me, or did Top Cow make a real effort to keep this comic a relatively T & A free as possible? Features a framing story that leads into introductions of the main characters of their superhero universe.
Top Shelf Productions

Owly and Friends!
Notes: Short stories featuring Owly, Korgi, Johnny Boo, and Yam. Really great for kids.
Twomorrows Publishing

Comics Go Hollywood
Notes: An interesting mix of articles including the 1984 X-Men movie that never was, and Jack Kirby's projects for motion pictures.
Viper Comics

Kid Houdini and the Silver Dollar Misfits
Notes: Previews of Kid Houdini & The Sleepy Truth
Virgin Comics
Free Comic Book Day 2008
Notes: Previews of The Stranded & Dan Dare
Viz Media
Shonen Jump Special 2008
Notes: Features three stories, including Naruto.
Wildcard Ink

Gumby Free Comic Book Day Edition
Notes: This is the first time I've read any of the issues of this new Gumby series spearheaded by Bob Burden, and I must say I like the blend of kids comic with an edgy, underground feel.
Wizard Entertainment

How To Draw: Free Comic Book Day Booklet
Notes: Selections from their How To Draw Comics book.
Yen Press

Maximum Ride: The Manga
Notes: Preview of the manga series by James Patterson. Yen Press is part of the Hachette Book Group.